Revaz Nadaraia to Zaza Bibilashvili: To a certain extent, indirectly, you have insulted the court when you cast doubt on our impartiality – you are expressing disrespect and this too will have its limit, take note!

Revaz Nadaraia to Zaza Bibilashvili: To a certain extent, indirectly, you have insulted the court when you cast doubt on our impartiality – you are expressing disrespect and this too will have its limit, take note!

Are you responding to the lawsuit or criticizing us because of our decision? Are you requesting our recusal or what do you want? To a certain extent, indirectly, you have insulted the court when you cast doubt on our impartiality – you are expressing disrespect and this too will have its limit, take note! – this is how Chairman of the Constitutional Court Revaz Nadaraia addressed the representative of the “National Movement,” Zaza Bibilashvili, who noted that they have no illusions whatsoever regarding the outcome of this process.

Nadaraia interrupted Zaza Bibilashvili’s presentation of the response to the lawsuit, in which the representative of the “National Movement” was speaking about Manana Kobakhidze’s self-recusal and the Constitutional Court’s position on this matter.

“There were moments voiced in your passage about which we had agreed that the parties should not speak. You must respond legally to the extent to which grounds for a ban exist,” Nadaraia addressed Zaza Bibilashvili.

As Bibilashvili noted in his reply, it is not the opinions he voiced that are insulting, but the statements of that high-ranking official who, according to Bibilashvili, declared that “the fate of the process is decided and only a few days remain.”

“In my opinion, if I were in your place, it would be an insult if a representative of one of the parties, who is formally the most powerful official in this country, said that the fate of this case is decided and only a few days remain. This is a person who has concrete levers over the life and career of everyone in this country. I have not allowed myself anything of the sort. I have not expressed disrespect,” Bibilashvili stated.

In Bibilashvili’s response, which was interrupted by the Chairman of the Constitutional Court, the representative of the defendant side noted that the fact that they should have no expectations regarding the process was confirmed by Manana Kobakhidze’s self-recusal and the Constitutional Court’s position on this matter, which did not see grounds for doubt regarding impartiality in Manana Kobakhidze’s past, her statements and the positions she held.

“You will forgive me if I say that we have no illusions whatsoever regarding the outcome of this process. The fact that we should have no expectations was confirmed, as if involuntarily, both by Manana Kobakhidze’s self-recusal, which you did not grant, and by her subsequent resignation. I repeat, Manana Kobakhidze herself stated that a judge must not only be impartial but must also be perceived by society as impartial, which is a basic standard in this profession, and the Constitutional Court considered that her past, political activity, her statements, her positions as the lawyer and one of the closest and most trusted persons of the chairman of the plaintiff party, Bidzina Ivanishvili, did not even provide grounds for anyone in society to cast doubt on her bias. I am not saying that she was biased, but you declared that even grounds for doubt did not exist,” Bibilashvili stated.