Revaz Nadaraia to Gvaramia: "Your position on vetting - that a specific judge should be removed, and so on - is clear; let’s not get into that. I have no information regarding corruption among judges. You are raising this issue in a provocative manner - show some respect for the court!"

"I have no information regarding corrupt judges. You are raising the issue in a provocative manner; first and foremost, show some respect for the judicial system." This was the response from Revaz Nadaraia, a judge of the Constitutional Court, to Nika Gvaramia—a representative for the "Coalition for Change"—who, during the hearing of a case concerning the potential banning of opposition parties, asked Judge Nadaraia: "Do you not agree that corrupt judges should be removed from the system?"
According to Nika Gvaramia, he finds it unclear why the plaintiff's side cited the vetting procedure as an example of an attack on the constitutional order.
"I do not know for what purpose the plaintiff mentioned the 'vetting' procedure as an example of an attack on the constitutional order; it is completely incomprehensible to me. Surely, corrupt judges should be removed from the system. Do you not agree that corrupt judges ought to be removed from the system?
“I stated that a corrupt judge has no place in the system—that is as clear as two plus two equals four. The purpose of vetting is to identify such judges and, if found, to remove them. This is what the vetting procedure entails, and it would be carried out based on Georgian legislation. However, this would likely require constitutional amendments; no one intends—nor is it even possible—to proceed without following the necessary constitutional or parliamentary legislative procedures. It is therefore baffling how this could be construed as an attack on the constitutional order. Vetting is, in fact, nothing more than an attack on corruption—an objective that I hope 'Georgian Dream' still considers legitimate," stated Gvaramia.
Judge Nadaraia interrupted Gvaramia, noting that his position—that the vetting procedure is not contrary to the constitutional order—was understood; however, he urged him not to elaborate further on his views regarding the structure of the judiciary during the hearing.
"I understand the context of your point—that the demand for vetting is not considered unconstitutional. Let’s not get into arguments about which specific judges should be dismissed or similar matters; that is not the issue here. The substance of your position is perfectly clear, so please stick to the point you are making.
I have no information regarding corruption among judges. You are framing this issue in a provocative manner—please refrain from doing so! First and foremost, show respect for the judicial system! The judicial system encompasses both the Constitutional Court and the courts of general jurisdiction—respect both of them! It is clear that, in your view, the demand for vetting—or reform of the judicial system—is not contrary to the Constitution. As for your personal opinions on how the judicial system should be structured, please discuss those elsewhere. That is merely your own perspective," the judge stated.








