The Constitutional Court plenum did not satisfy the motion of the "National Movement" representative, stating that rulings already adopted are not subject to revision

"Let's figure it out—does this lawsuit have evidence or not? Figure out the charges presented by us, which are numerous regarding systemic crimes, and whether you have answers," Archil Gorduladze, the representative of "Georgian Dream" in the Constitutional Court, stated in response to the motion by Zaza Bibilashvili, the representative of the "National Movement."
Zaza Bibilashvili's motion included 3 aspects, and its primary demand in relation to this specific case was for the court to define specific standards.
"Let the Constitutional Court adopt a ruling or issue a written explanation before resolving the case on its merits, which defines in the case of banning political parties: 1. The subject of proof in relation to each precondition provided for by Article 23 of the Constitution of Georgia for each respondent. 2. The rule of distribution of the burden of proof, taking into account the presumption of constitutionality of political activities' of political parties. 3. The standard of proof and standards for evaluating evidence — this is our motion, and I repeat once again, we are tackling such a massive case as citizens of this country that I do not know how 20-30 minutes, or even a day, could be connected to the possible catastrophic consequences that might follow this case, not only through the banning of parties, but also through what Russia will 'whitewash' with this lawsuit. The court faces the following choice: to define the standards now and thereby give the parties the opportunity to fully defend their interests and consequently the interests of the country, or later, post-factum, tell us in an already adopted decision what we could and should have known now. Especially under conditions when your ruling has established that these standards do not exist and need to be determined. Let those standards be established through an interim decision or explanation, with which we must defend ourselves in the remaining procedural stages now," Bibilashvili stated.
The plaintiff's side responded to this motion by the "National Movement," explaining that Zaza Bibilashvili was using the high tribune to make political statements, that his motion strayed from legal issues, and that he spoke incorrectly about facts.
"Mr. Zaza Bibilashvili used the tribune to do everything that had already been said during the explanations—the purpose of this is also interesting. It strays entirely from legal issues, and he also made statements on political issues. He addressed us, and as for facts, he spoke about them entirely incorrectly. Do you know what the main thing is? 'Zaza, come back immediately and show class, remind them that a successful state was created under the hands of numerous betrayals by a group of successful politicians' — these are the words of Mikheil Saakashvili. Over three days of answering judges' questions, quoting a judge from European Court of Human Rights decisions, and answering questions in a way that wasn't what they might have given, they filed a motion for the judge's recusal so that such questions would no longer be asked. Despite the fact that more than one lie was voiced specifically by representatives of the 'National Movement' and that these lies deserve an appropriate assessment by society, Mr. Zaza now used this tribune to make a political speech, including telling an absolute lie regarding the 30th anniversary of the court. Turns out, how dare the Chairman of Parliament attend a specific event? Mr. Zaza, I know about your qualifications and I am sure you well know that in the case of norm-control, in the absolute majority of cases, the Parliament of Georgia is the respondent, and what are we to do? Because it is the respondent and the Chairman of Parliament signs the mandate regarding specific representatives, does that mean he should not attend any event of the Constitutional Court?
What is the 'National Movement' asking for? If, for example, for 'New Changes,' Mr. Gramamia was demanding just a few days ago that one of the components of the decision—that is, when it should enter into force—be announced in advance and a decision be adopted, now Mr. Zaza Bibilashvili is demanding that the plenum deliberate in advance and establish what standards should be used and how specific facts should be evaluated. Let's figure it out—does this lawsuit have evidence or not? Figure out the charges presented by us, which are numerous regarding systemic crimes, and whether you have answers, and stop returning to where we were 13 days ago. It's the 14th day, and 13 days ago you were saying 'we don't know who is challenging us,' and today you come out when the judges have almost finished answering the parties and you are still saying 'we don't know who is challenging us.' You simply cannot do this, and I ask you, Mr. Judge, to ensure that the high tribune is not used to make political statements and to return to the stage that a specific party has already passed," Gorduladze stated.
The judges' plenum did not satisfy the motion of "National Movement" representative Zaza Bibilashvili and stated that "rulings adopted by the court plenum are not subject to revision."
"The motion should not be satisfied and is not satisfied due to the following circumstances: the party is practically appealing, and with the content of its motion, it dislikes the rulings that were issued by the plenum during the case review stage in response to the parties' motion. Rulings adopted by the court plenum are not subject to revision. As for the standard of evidence, it is read in a certain way that the party wants the court to tell it in advance what evidence it will use for what and for what purpose. This is unbelievable," Revaz Nadaraia stated.








